I think the 2 selected tomorrow night will be: Erskine Diana Matt & Katie might surprise. Fantasia was horrible, but she might get votes based on what Simon said. My picks.. Erskine & Diana.

My God how did she make it this far. This song has always sucked "Let's give them something to talk about" but this is probably the worst ive heard it. Yikes. Judges My god these people like her. Come on Simon..She isn't that good. Simon called her a star and said she didn't need this competition. Am In the twilight Zone?

This guy is singing "walking in memphis" He's ok. Minor crowd reaction so far. Nothing Spectacular Judges: Randy - not good enough Paula - She liked him, but it was painful to hear her explain it. Simon - looks good, "bigger steps" than Clay Aiken He might make it, he has the cute factor.

I don't like this. I don't think she's that good. Its not going to stand up next to the Diana and Erskine. judges Randy Disappointed Paula - "nice" Simon - Simon liked her.

I don't remember this fella from the audition shows. Pretty good. This crowd is gonna pop for him. Justin with short hair, maybe. Judges: Randy liked him. more gibberish from Paula Simon - He's not happy with the 'safeness' of the song selection. Compared him to chinese food. He was pretty good.

Well she's hot enough to make the cut, I remember her being better than this, maybe is the song she's singing. I don't like it. Some Jazz tune. Judges Randy liked her, Paula didn't like the song. Simon was Simon. Bar Singer

To quote Obi Wan- I've got a bad feeling about this. Yikes, She is horrible. Good Night ashley, this is your last performance on American Idol, I hope. Judges: Not very good from the Judges. Simon is railin' on her. Great stuff. RODEO YEE HAW

Like he said he had a tough act to follow. He's ok, but pretty bland so far. Very little crowd reaction. Judges: As usual Randy & Paula like him, Simon liked him, but challenged song selection. He's ok, he might make the cut tonight.

Black And Pink Girl. Very nice performance tonight. They have changed these first rounds by having a band and an audience. Maybe they had these last season, but don't remember. She was very good tonight. Getting good praises from the judges.

American Idol will be starting shortly. I will be posting my opinions on each singer afterwards, sometimes during if they are bad.